In today’s fast-paced digital landscape, e-commerce has become a major force for businesses of all sizes, enabling companies and individuals to buy and sell goods and services online. E-commerce spans various market segments and can be conducted via computers, tablets, smartphones, and other smart devices. The Indian e-commerce market has witnessed unprecedented growth over the past decade. According to reports, the market was valued at approximately USD 84 billion in 2021 and is projected to reach USD 200 billion by 2027. This growth trajectory is driven by increasing internet penetration, widespread smartphone usage, and a significant shift in consumer shopping behavior towards online platforms.

Given this vast scope, it’s crucial to consider the tax implications—both direct and indirect—that accompany e-commerce. These tax implications can be complex and vary depending on the jurisdiction, the nature of the business, and the types of transactions involved. Additionally, e-commerce taxation is a rapidly evolving field, with tax regulations subject to frequent changes, making continuous monitoring and compliance necessary for businesses operating in this space.

Resident and Non-resident

The tax liability of an individual in India is determined by their residential status for a given financial year. An individual is considered a resident if they:

• Are physically present in India for 182 days or more during the financial year, or
• Are physically present in India for 60 days or more during the financial year and 365 days or more in the preceding four years.

Additionally, in case of citizens leaving India for the purposes of employment or citizens visiting India, the condition of 60 days prescribed above was to be replaced with 182 days.

However, the Finance Act, 2020, effective from Assessment Year 2021-22, further amended this to 120 days for Indian citizens or persons of Indian origin visiting India with total income exceeding INR 15 lakhs, excluding foreign income.

If neither condition is met, the individual is classified as a non-resident for that financial year.

Illustration 1: Flowchart: Determining Residential Status Based on Period of Stay

Resident Digital Tax Compliance

Digital tax compliance for Indian residents engaging in e-commerce involves adhering to various tax regulations, primarily under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime. Below is an in-depth exploration of these requirements:

GST Registration

All e-commerce operators and suppliers must register for GST irrespective of their turnover. This mandatory registration ensures that every entity participating in e-commerce transactions is within the tax net, facilitating proper tax collection and compliance.

Tax Collection at Source (TCS)

E-commerce operators are obligated to collect TCS at the rate of 1% ( In 53^rd GST council meeting  held on 22 June 2024, It is recommended to reduce this to 0.5 %) on the net value of taxable supplies made through their platform. This TCS is deducted when the amount is credited to the e-commerce participant’s account or when payment is made. The collected TCS must be deposited with the government and reported in the monthly GST returns.

Filing GST Returns

E-commerce businesses are required to file various GST returns:

• GSTR-1: Details of outward supplies.
• GSTR-3B: Summary return of sales and input tax credit.
• GSTR-9: Annual return consolidating all monthly returns.GSTR- 8: A Statement of TCS (Tax Collected at Source) to be filed by E Commerce Operators.

Accurate and timely filing of these returns is crucial to avoid penalties and ensure compliance. Proper accounting systems and professional expertise are often necessary to manage this process efficiently.

Place of Supply Rules

These rules determine the location where a supply of goods or services is deemed to take place, which affects the tax jurisdiction:

• Goods: The place of supply is where the delivery terminates as per the direction of the recipient. For intra-state supplies, CGST and SGST are applicable, while for inter-state supplies, IGST is levied.
• Services: The place of supply is generally where the recipient is located. Specific services like those related to immovable property have their place of supply where the property is located.

Understanding these rules is essential for determining whether CGST, SGST, or IGST applies to a transaction.

Record Keeping

Maintaining comprehensive and accurate records of all transactions is vital for compliance and audit readiness. This includes:

• Invoices: Properly documented invoices for every transaction.
• Receipts: Proof of payment received.
• TCS Documentation: Evidence of TCS collected and remitted.

Efficient record-keeping practices facilitate seamless compliance and help in substantiating tax filings during audits.

Technology Integration

Leveraging advanced accounting and tax compliance software can streamline processes, reduce errors, and ensure timely submissions. Automation tools can handle complex calculations, generate accurate reports, and keep businesses updated with the latest regulatory changes.

Regular Updates and Training

Continuous training for finance and compliance teams is essential to stay informed about the latest GST regulations and compliance requirements. Regular workshops, webinars, and consultation with tax experts can significantly enhance compliance readiness and ensure that businesses are well-prepared to handle any regulatory changes.

Compliance with E-Invoicing Requirements

E-commerce businesses must comply with e-invoicing mandates set by the GST Council:

• E-Invoicing Thresholds: Businesses exceeding specified turnover thresholds are required to generate electronic invoices through the government’s e-invoicing portal. As of now, businesses with a turnover exceeding Rs. 5 crore must comply, but this threshold is subject to change.
• IRN Generation: Each invoice must have an Invoice Reference Number (IRN) generated by the e-invoicing system.
• QR Codes: E-invoices must include a QR code containing essential invoice details to facilitate verification.

Compliance with e-invoicing not only ensures adherence to regulations but also streamlines the invoicing process and reduces the risk of errors and fraud.

Non-resident Digital Tax Compliance

Non-Indian residents conducting e-commerce in India must navigate specific digital tax compliance requirements to ensure their operations remain lawful and efficient. Below are the key aspects of compliance:

Equalisation Levy

The Equalisation Levy was introduced to tax digital transactions by non-resident companies deriving income from Indian customers. Initially imposed at 6% on online advertisements and related services, its scope was broadened in 2020 to include a 2% levy on the consideration received by non-resident e-commerce operators for goods and services sold online to Indian customers.  However, the recently enacted budget 2024 has removed the equalization levy on digital transactions while the original equalization levy of 6% on offshore firms hosting advertisements for Indian consumers continues to be applicable even post Budget 2024 being enacted.

Goods and Services Tax (GST)

Non-resident e-commerce operators must adhere to GST rules when providing goods and services to Indian residents, even though they do not pay GST directly.

Place of Supply Rules

• Goods: The place of supply for goods imported into India is the location of the importer, typically an Indian entity.
• Services: For services rendered to Indian residents, the place of supply is where the recipient is located. Services provided to non-residents are considered exports and are zero-rated under GST.

Documentation and Record-Keeping

Maintaining detailed records is essential for compliance. This includes:

• Invoices: Properly documented invoices for each transaction.
• Receipts: Proof of payment received from Indian customers.
• Tax Payments: Documentation of Equalisation Levy payments.

Proper documentation is crucial for compliance verification and audits by Indian tax authorities.

Technological Integration

Adopting robust accounting and tax compliance software can streamline the management of tax obligations, ensuring timely and accurate submissions. Automation tools can handle complex tax calculations, generate compliance reports, and keep businesses updated on regulatory changes.

Consultation with Tax Experts

Engaging with tax professionals who understand Indian tax laws can provide valuable guidance, helping non-resident businesses navigate the complexities of digital tax compliance. Tax experts can assist in optimizing tax strategies, ensuring accurate filings, and staying compliant with evolving regulations.

Challenges in Digital Tax Compliance

Multiple Registrations

E-commerce businesses operating across multiple states may need to register in each state where they have a significant presence or sales, leading to increased administrative burdens. This requirement can be particularly onerous for SMEs, which may lack the resources to manage multi-state registrations effectively.

Complexity in Return Filing

The requirement to file multiple GST returns, including monthly and annual filings, can be complex and time-consuming. Businesses must ensure accurate reporting of sales, purchases, and tax credits, which often necessitates the use of sophisticated accounting software and professional accounting services.

TCS and Equalisation Levy Compliance

Accurate management of TCS and Equalisation Levy collection and reporting is crucial, as discrepancies can result in penalties and legal complications. This involves not only correct calculation and deduction but also timely remittance and reporting to the tax authorities.

Dynamic Regulatory Environment

The digital tax compliance landscape is continually evolving, with frequent changes in regulations and compliance requirements. Keeping abreast of these changes poses a significant challenge, particularly for businesses without dedicated tax compliance teams.

Import and Export Regulations

Understanding the GST implications on import and export transactions, including the applicability of IGST on imports and the procedures for claiming refunds or exemptions on exports.

Insights and Best Practices for Navigating Digital Tax Compliance

Leveraging Technology

Adopting advanced accounting and tax compliance software can streamline GST registration, return filing, and management of TCS and Equalisation Levy. These tools can automate calculations, ensure timely submissions, and minimize the risk of errors. Technology can also help businesses stay updated with regulatory changes through automated updates and compliance checks.

Regular Training and Updates

E-commerce businesses should invest in continuous training for their finance and compliance teams to stay informed about the latest regulatory changes and compliance requirements. Regular workshops, webinars, and consultation with tax experts can significantly enhance compliance readiness.

Robust Record-Keeping

Maintaining accurate and comprehensive records of all transactions is essential for seamless GST and Equalisation Levy compliance. This includes invoices, receipts, and proof of TCS and Equalisation Levy collection. Proper documentation ensures that businesses can substantiate their tax filings in case of audits or disputes.

Cloud-Based Solutions

Adoption of cloud-based tax compliance solutions allows for real-time updates, seamless integration with other business systems, and scalable infrastructure to handle growing data volumes.

Consultation with Tax Experts

Engaging with tax professionals and consultants can provide valuable guidance on complex compliance issues and aid in navigating the regulatory landscape effectively. Tax experts can help businesses interpret regulations correctly, optimize their tax strategies, and ensure timely compliance.

Future Trends and Developments

Integration of Digital Tax Platforms

The Indian government is increasingly focusing on integrating digital platforms for seamless tax compliance. The implementation of e-invoicing and the GST Network (GSTN) portal are significant steps towards creating a more transparent and efficient tax administration system. These platforms facilitate real-time tracking of transactions and ensure greater accuracy in tax reporting.

Emphasis on Data Analytics

Leveraging data analytics to monitor compliance and detect anomalies is expected to become more prevalent. Advanced analytics can help tax authorities identify non-compliance patterns and enhance the efficiency of tax administration. For businesses, data analytics can provide insights into compliance trends and help optimize tax strategies.

Global Harmonization of Digital Taxes

As e-commerce transcends borders, there is a growing need for harmonization of digital tax regulations at an international level. Initiatives by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and other bodies aim to create a cohesive framework for digital taxation. Such harmonization would simplify compliance for multinational e-commerce businesses and reduce the risk of double taxation.

Overview of OIDAR Services

OIDAR (Online Information and Database Access or Retrieval) services are delivered over the Internet with minimal human intervention, allowing recipients to receive services online without physical interaction with the provider. The inclusion of OIDAR services under GST aims to level the playing field for domestic service providers in terms of cost. Examples of OIDAR services include downloadable software and applications, cloud services, online gaming platforms, digital content distribution (e.g., e-books, music, videos), online education and training, web hosting and maintenance, online advertising, electronic data interchange (EDI) services, search engine services, and digital data storage solutions.

GST Rate and HSN Code for OIDAR Services

The Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) rate for these digital services in India is 18%, except for the online sale of e-books under HSN code 9984, which is taxed at a reduced rate of 5%.

GST Registration Requirements for OIDAR Services

All entities providing OIDAR services in India, regardless of turnover, must register under GST. This requirement also applies to OIDAR service providers located outside India who offer services to Indian residents. If the service provider is in a non-taxable territory and the recipient is a non-taxable online recipient (NTOR), the intermediary supplying the services must register and pay GST.

Filing of Returns for OIDAR Services

According to Rule 64 of the CGST Rules, 2017, every registered person providing OIDAR services from outside India to a non-taxable recipient in India must file a return in form GSTR-5A by the 20th day of the following month. Overseas service providers must adhere to this schedule. Other OIDAR service providers must file their returns in regular forms such as GSTR-1, GSTR-2, or GSTR-3, along with annual tax returns as applicable. Notably, there is no provision for input tax credit for OIDAR suppliers.

Conclusion

Navigating digital tax compliance for e-commerce in India is a multifaceted challenge that requires a thorough understanding of GST regulations, robust processes, and the use of technology. By adopting best practices and staying informed about regulatory changes, e-commerce businesses can ensure compliance and contribute to a transparent and efficient tax ecosystem. The future of digital tax compliance holds promise for greater integration, enhanced use of data analytics, and international cooperation, paving the way for a more streamlined and equitable tax landscape.  Further, with OIDAR services being prevalent in India. Understanding GST impact and ensuring compliance is crucial for these service providers. Registering for GST and fulfilling return obligations allows OIDAR providers to meet legal requirements and support a transparent tax system, promoting India’s digital economy.

Share via